Brazilians Support Bolsa Família Welfare

By Lucy Jordan, Senior Contributing Reporter

BRASÍLIA, BRAZIL – New research shows nearly three-quarters of Brazilians are in favor of continuing the Bolsa Família, an anti-poverty program that gives cash to families in return for ensuring their children attend school and are vaccinated. Most Brazilians, sixty percent, would rather pay more taxes and have better universal health and education, the research showed.

The Bolsa Família program serves more than 13 million, Brazil News

The Bolsa Família program serves more than 13 million households in Brazil, photo by Divulgação/MDS.

The Bolsa Família program was expanded significantly under former-President Lula in 2003. Under the program, poor families receive cash, conditional on their children attending school and health clinics.

The domestic welfare system has been credited with contributing toward a large reduction in poverty in Brazil and has even been reproduced overseas in cities, including New York.

However, some observers have questioned whether cash handouts are a long-term solution to poverty, and attribute the past decade’s poverty reduction to sustained economic growth.

“I noticed a strong support for social policies in Brazil – of Bolsa Família and of the minimum wage as well as a minimum pension, universal education and public health: all with percentages well above fifty percent,” said Celia Kerstenetzky, UFF Professor and coordinator of the Center for Research on Inequality and Development, in an interview.

However, the data also showed that more than fifty percent of Brazilians don’t believe the program is effective at bringing families out of poverty, while almost forty percent believe that the poor stay poor more for want of effort than a lack of opportunities.

The Bolsa Família program was expanded significantly in 2003, Brazil News

The domestic welfare system has been credited with contributing toward a large reduction in poverty in Brazil, photo by Paula Fróes/Sedes/BA.

Published Monday in Globo, the research was overseen by Professor Lena Lavinas of the Institute of Economics of UFRJ, and used a sample of 2,200 adults over sixteen to gauge public opinion about income inequality and anti-poverty measures.

“It is quite obvious that the way out from poverty cannot come through handouts – on the contrary,” said Antony Mueller, professor of economics at the Federal University of Sergipe, in an interview. “In as much a significant portions of Brazilian could make their way out of poverty and enter the middle class was because the Brazilian economy had a pretty long period of good performance.”

Presented with the statement “There will always be poor, so programs like Bolsa Família should not end,” 73.2 percent either agreed or strongly agreed. Only 16.2 percent disagreed, either moderately or totally, with the statement. More than sixty percent agree completely that the government should intervene to reduce inequalities between rich and poor.

“Brazil is really moving toward the European model of the welfare state,” said David Fleischer, professor emeritus of political science at the University of Brasília, in an interview. “No sane politician would propose abolishing Bolsa Família. It would be political suicide because there is such a large margin of public support for it.”

Despite widespread support for the program, the Brazilian population is split over whether the value of the benefit should be increased: although 63 percent of the sample believes that the cash benefit is small, 42 percent believe it should be increased, and 42 percent oppose an increase. Presented with the statement “Bolsa Família takes many people from poverty”, 58.9 percent disagreed to some degree.

Professor Kerstenetzky said the survey shows the Brazilian population is clearly in favor of the idea that the state is responsible for trying to reduce inequality, even if there are some divisions over the ways it should do so.

“The survey revealed strong support of the Brazilian redistributive function of the state and a major concern with inequality, along with the idea that it is the government’s responsibility to contribute to its reduction,” she said.

14 Responses to "Brazilians Support Bolsa Família Welfare"

  1. Pingback: Editorial: In the Middle of It | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  2. Paulo C F Viana  January 16, 2013 at 1:00 PM

    As usual on this “researches” and “opinion polls” about gop popularity and performance, the population targeted on the interviews is strongly skewed towards the approval. The current Bolsa Familia, without the obligation of a counterpart such as showing proof of chindren in school as existed in the original program, is NOT supported by the majority of the thinking population that in the end, funds the program through some of the highest taxes in the world. The gop has no interest in educating the lower classes as they are votes that can be easily bought, sometimes for a denture, sometimes by shoes or other apparently insignificant items. All one has to do is travel to the North of the country, specially Maranhao and Piaui states, to see the negative results of this program. No one wants to work, most people live from bolsa this and bolsa that…

  3. Juan  January 16, 2013 at 7:52 PM

    Birth control must also be one of the conditions to support the poor through government programs.

  4. Marcio Camacho Aznar  February 11, 2013 at 5:33 AM

    By offering the bolsa familia to parents whose kids are in school the government ensures these kids will be educated and will be able to get jobs at an adult age.

  5. Pingback: Lula Backs President Rousseff for Second Term | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  6. Pingback: Rumor Sparks Mass Bolsa Família Withdrawals: Daily Update | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  7. Pingback: Caixa Boss Admits Bolsa Blunder: Daily Update | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  8. Stefano Sacchi  June 25, 2013 at 12:56 PM

    Do not give them a fish, teach them how to fish, in other words, create the conditions.
    One of these could be the access to the credit, the interest rates are absurd, brazilians are used to live together with debts and to play the 3 card game using the XXX bank credit card to pay the bill of the YYY bank credit card, to have some money to spend, the average brazilian will withdraw money with the ZZZ bank credit card; is this middle class?
    To protect the local industry does not mean that the cost of the inefficiency and of the lack of innovation has to be paid by the citizens.
    If an imported good costs 100 because is overloaded with a 100% import tax, the brazilian good that could be sold at 60 is sold at 90 instead, the custo Brasil is fully backcharged to brazilians.
    Make Brazil more affordable, with some more money in the pocket, the entrepreneur spirit grows easier.

  9. Pingback: Brazil Municipal Human Development Index Up Fifty Percent in Twenty Years | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  10. Pingback: Brazil 2014 FIFA World Cup Tickets on Sale: Daily Update | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  11. Pingback: Campos and Silva to Run for PSB Party in Brazil | The Rio Times | Brazil News

  12. Pingback: Social workers channel Indiana Jones to deliver welfare checks to Brazil’s Amazon | World News Source

  13. Pingback: Social workers channel Indiana Jones to deliver welfare checks to Brazil’s Amazon | News Today

  14. Pingback: Social workers channel Indiana Jones to deliver welfare checks to Brazil’s Amazon | The News Gazette

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.