IBOV 169,865.13 ▲ 0.34% IPC MEX 71,204.98 ▼ 0.84% MERVAL 2,848,945 — — USD/BRL5.78▼ 0.11% USD/MXN18.42▼ 0.52% USD/CLP991.61▼ 0.79% USD/COP3,300▼ 0.53% USD/PEN3.41▲ 0.12% USD/ARS1,552▲ 0.14% USD/UYU40.61▲ 3.40% USD/PYG6,212▲ 3.22% USD/BOB11.64▲ 2.89% USD/DOP60.27▲ 1.93% USD/CRC441.73▲ 1.57% USD/GTQ7.64▲ 3.17% USD/HNL26.89▲ 2.99% USD/NIO36.62▲ 2.50% USD/VES913.46▼ 0.13% USD/PAB1.00— 0.00% USD/BZD2.00— 0.00% USD/JMD157.69▲ 2.79% USD/TTD6.70▲ 1.69% EUR/BRL6.36▲ 1.94% BRENT 93.48 ▲ 1.13% WTI 86.54 ▲ 0.96% IRON ORE 161.91 — — COPPER 5.99 ▼ 0.06% GOLD 3,859 ▲ 0.15% SILVER 47.34 ▲ 1.19% SOY 1,230 ▲ 0.06% CORN 448.75 — 0.00% WHEAT 612.00 ▲ 4.26% COFFEE 279.95 ▼ 0.27% SUGAR 18.17 ▲ 0.39% ORANGE JUICE 134.20 ▼ 1.43% COTTON 81.30 ▲ 5.58% COCOA 5,184 ▲ 2.82% BEEF 222.85 ▲ 1.15% CATTLE 328.58 ▼ 2.61% LITHIUM 56.46 ▼ 0.67% PETR4 44.08 ▲ 0.14% VALE3 60.61 ▼ 0.15% ITUB4 40.67 ▼ 1.53% BBDC4 14.27 ▲ 0.28% ABEV3 15.88 ▲ 0.06% BBAS3 14.97 ▲ 0.13% B3SA3 14.67 ▼ 0.95% WEGE3 51.41 ▲ 2.00% PRIO3 64.41 ▲ 2.84% SUZB3 55.74 ▲ 0.43% RENT3 29.52 ▲ 0.72% AZZA3 15.77 ▼ 2.29% CSAN3 3.17 ▲ 2.59% RAIZ4 19.11 ▼ 4.45% PCAR3 2.76 ▲ 6.15% GMAT3 4.16 ▲ 0.73% PSSA3 46.00 ▲ 1.01% CVCB3 0.80 ▲ 1.27% POSI3 3.12 ▲ 0.65% SLCE3 17.95 ▲ 0.56% NATU3 4.77 ▼ 2.65% BRKM5 2.77 ▼ 2.46% RANI3 8.28 ▲ 1.10% CSNA3 3.88 ▲ 5.43% IBOV 169,865.13 ▲ 0.34% IPC MEX 71,204.98 ▼ 0.84% MERVAL 2,848,945 — — USD/BRL 5.77 ▼ 0.17% USD/MXN 18.42 ▼ 0.55% USD/CLP 991.91 ▼ 0.76% USD/COP 3,300 ▼ 0.53% USD/PEN 3.41 ▲ 0.05% USD/ARS 1,552 ▲ 0.14% USD/UYU 40.61 ▲ 3.40% USD/PYG 6,212 ▲ 3.22% USD/BOB 11.64 ▲ 2.89% USD/DOP 60.27 ▲ 1.93% USD/CRC 441.73 ▲ 1.57% USD/GTQ 7.64 ▲ 3.17% USD/HNL 26.89 ▲ 2.99% USD/NIO 36.62 ▲ 2.50% USD/VES 913.46 ▼ 0.13% USD/PAB 1.00 — 0.00% USD/BZD 2.00 — 0.00% USD/JMD 157.69 ▲ 2.79% USD/TTD 6.70 ▲ 1.69% EUR/BRL 6.36 ▲ 1.94% BRENT 93.48 ▲ 1.13% WTI 86.54 ▲ 0.96% IRON ORE 161.91 — — COPPER 5.99 ▼ 0.06% GOLD 3,859 ▲ 0.15% SILVER 47.34 ▲ 1.19% SOY 1,230 ▲ 0.06% CORN 448.75 — 0.00% WHEAT 612.00 ▲ 4.26% COFFEE 279.95 ▼ 0.27% SUGAR 18.17 ▲ 0.39% ORANGE JUICE 134.20 ▼ 1.43% COTTON 81.30 ▲ 5.58% COCOA 5,184 ▲ 2.82% BEEF 222.85 ▲ 1.15% CATTLE 328.58 ▼ 2.61% LITHIUM 56.46 ▼ 0.67% PETR4 44.08 ▲ 0.14% VALE3 60.61 ▼ 0.15% ITUB4 40.67 ▼ 1.53% BBDC4 14.27 ▲ 0.28% ABEV3 15.88 ▲ 0.06% BBAS3 14.97 ▲ 0.13% B3SA3 14.67 ▼ 0.95% WEGE3 51.41 ▲ 2.00% PRIO3 64.41 ▲ 2.84% SUZB3 55.74 ▲ 0.43% RENT3 29.52 ▲ 0.72% AZZA3 15.77 ▼ 2.29% CSAN3 3.17 ▲ 2.59% RAIZ4 19.11 ▼ 4.45% PCAR3 2.76 ▲ 6.15% GMAT3 4.16 ▲ 0.73% PSSA3 46.00 ▲ 1.01% CVCB3 0.80 ▲ 1.27% POSI3 3.12 ▲ 0.65% SLCE3 17.95 ▲ 0.56% NATU3 4.77 ▼ 2.65% BRKM5 2.77 ▼ 2.46% RANI3 8.28 ▲ 1.10% CSNA3 3.88 ▲ 5.43%
since 2009
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Opinion: The Curmudgeon on Marina’s Rise and Fall

By · · 3 min read

Opinion, by Michael Royster

RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL – The 2014 Brazilian Presidential elections are no longer “done and dusted” as the Curmudgeon imagined a month ago. The “hearts and minds” contest has been won by the minds. All these add up to: Marina Silva will not be the next President of Brazil, and Dilma may well be re-elected.

The Curmudgeon, aka Michael Royster
The Curmudgeon, aka Michael Royster.
RT
Ask Rio Times
17 years of Latin America reporting, on demand.
Open the full Ask Rio Times →

Four crucial things happened in the run-up to the first round of elections after Marina appeared: (1) she was tellingly (and accurately) portrayed as inexperienced in government by both Dilma and Aécio; (2) her performances in the televised debates were abysmal; (3) she announced an economic plan which seemed a carbon copy of Aécio’s; and (4) she caved on the question of alliances with other parties.

Marina’s surge in popularity can be partially attributed to voters who felt disenfranchised (“no party represents me”) and who protested in mid-2013. But as September progressed, Marina failed to offer voters any real plans for change – she even admitted her government would use experienced politicians from her rivals’ parties – PSDB and PT.

The Curmudgeon suspects that many potential Marina voters, whose hearts wanted real change, let their minds convince them she had become just another traditional politician. Therefore, they either stayed home, or voted for no presidential candidate, or purposely spoiled their ballot so it couldn’t be counted. Out of 142 million registered voters, only 104 million, or 73 percent, cast valid votes for the Presidency.

“It’s the economy, stupid” has been shown to have different meanings for different voters. The facts that Brazil formally entered a recession and that inflation was hovering at the tolerable limit, had no discernible effect on Dilma’s approval rating. This improved during September, because of her campaign’s emphasis on the popular (if not populist) measures that 12 years of Lula and Dilma had implanted.

The LatAm Brief

One email, every weekday morning. What moved in Latin American markets, politics and expat life.

Yesterday’s subject line: “US rule would require licences for AI chips to Brazil”

These programs include public works projects, which reduce unemployment. They include the “bolsa família” where the poorest receive a monthly allowance. They include real rises in the minimum salary. These are what poor voters think about when “the economy” is mentioned, and poor voters still far outnumber the non-poor.

Marina’s environmental emphasis was portrayed by Dilma as meaning fewer public works, thus meaning fewer jobs. She and Aécio were accused of wanting to abolish the “bolsa família”. Marina’s and Aécio’s claims that lower fuel and electricity bills would eventually worsen the economy because they were artificial, fell on deaf ears among voters who like stable prices.

Marina was often characterized as the darling of the “evangelical” voters; however, both her rivals successfully undercut her support among those voters. Neither favored legalizing abortion; neither favored criminalizing homophobia. Marina had to backtrack on several prior “liberal” positions and was seen as pandering to conservative evangelical voters.

The televised debates gave her a chance to show she had the requisite experience and to appear “presidential”. She did neither—she waffled on several issues, and her voice sounded querulous and ultimately unconvincing. Aécio did much better than her, so it is arguable that many voters wanting change, upon arriving at the polling station, decided that they’d rather go with someone with practical experience.

The Curmudgeon will leave for next week’s column, same time, same station, his thoughts on the second round of elections, including whether or not Marina, once “done and dusted”, has been “undone and dustbinned”.

Michael Royster, aka THE CURMUDGEON, fetched up on Carioca shores some 37 years ago and still loves them; his favorite spectator sport is politics, viewed from a WASP-like perspective.

This article was produced by The Rio Times’ automated AI newsroom. Editorial responsibility: Matthias Camenzind, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief. The Rio Times also runs Ask Rio Times, which answers from 100,000+ of our own articles, the daily Latin America Power Map, and prediction-market odds on elections and markets.. How we use AI · Report an error

Read More from The Rio Times

The Rio Times · Power Map
See who really holds power in Latin America
Click to open the Power Map →

Brazil runoff date: Sunday, October 25, poll closing times and when results start · Brazil runoff polls: Flávio 51%, Lula 49% · Kalshi and Polymarket odds

Rotate for Best Experience

This report is optimized for landscape viewing. Rotate your phone for the full experience.